Ancient and modern pronunciations
Ancient and modern pronunciations
Annotation
This
course paper deals with new ways and methods of correcting students’
pronunciation mistakes. Teaching English pronunciation is important and actual
nowadays, so problems of teaching pronunciation and correcting students’
mistakes in pronouncing are discovered in this course paper. There are a
variety of good methods and techniques suggested for correcting learners' errors on the
spot. Mistakes are part of our life; we all make mistakes now and then. There
is nothing wrong with making mistakes as long as we learn from them and avoid
repeating them over and over. Additional information has been obtained from the
literature on the subject, to verify and assess the findings of the present
study.
Introduction
deals with the description of such items as: actuality of the problem, the aim,
the objects, the subject, the tasks, the methods, the sources.
Theoretical
part deals with the perceptions of The importance of teaching English pronunciation, Modelling
pronunciation, Aspects of pronunciation, The Role of Teaching
Pronunciation in FLT.
Practical
part deals with the correcting learners’ pronunciation mistakes, the ways and
methods of correcting students pronunciation mistakes, Correcting Without
Hurting, Exercises for the Pronunciation of Plurals for English second
language.
Conclusion
deals with the summary of all practical materials concerning the correcting
learners’ pronunciation mistakes.
Contents
Introduction
1. The importance of teaching English pronunciation
1.1 Ancient and Modern Pronunciations
1.2 Listening and
pronunciation
1.3 Modelling pronunciation
1.4 Performance of a text
1.5 Aspects of pronunciation
1.6 The Role of Teaching
Pronunciation in FLT
2. Correcting learners’ pronunciation
mistakes
2.1 New ways of correcting spoken errors
2.2 Correcting Without Hurting
2.3 Mistakes Made During Discussions and
Activities
2.4 Problems of correcting students’
pronunciation
2.5 Exercises for the Pronunciation of Plurals
for English second language
Conclusion
Bibliography
Appendix
Introduction
Actuality
of the research work.
A lot
of time and effort is spent on training courses and beyond in encouraging
teachers to consider whether immediate or later correction of student errors
during oral work is appropriate. There are a variety of good methods and
techniques suggested for correcting students' errors on the spot. Mistakes are
part of our life; we all make mistakes now and then. There is nothing wrong
with making mistakes as long as we learn from them and avoid repeating them
over and over.
To
correct students’ errors has always been, and will always be the concern of
most teachers. Some teachers are in favor of immediate correction, while others
are in favor of delayed correction. Some would even go further to consider the
whole process as time–consuming. In this article, I would like to dwell, based
on my practical experience, upon this controversial issue to offer some
suggestions for both immediate and delayed correction.
When
students are corrected in front of their classmates, they feel offended and get
discouraged. They expect teachers to continually correct them during classes.
Failure to do so is likely to create confusion and suspicion on the part of the
students. As such, teachers are expected to strive to find most creative ways
to deal with this problem that most typically arises. They need to encourage
and stimulate their students to participate in class without any fear of making
mistakes.
Most
students refuse to answer to the teacher in the classroom on the ground that
they are most likely to be the laughingstock of their class fellows.
Consequently, they get discouraged and feel humiliated. They refrain from
responding to the teacher’s questions which may deprive them of a valuable
learning opportunity.
Generally
speaking, there are three types of oral mistakes that need to be corrected
during class-discussion. These are: grammatical, vocabulary, and pronunciation
mistakes. This leads us to a very important question: should we interrupt our
students during discussion or avoid interrupting them as much as we can? To
answer this question we need to ask ourselves whether the focus is on accuracy
or fluency. In fact, to save our students the embarrassment and in order not to
distract them, we can employ less provocative approaches. One way is to make
notes of the most common mistakes made by a student to be discussed later.
Write them on the board without revealing the name of the student in order not
embarrass him/her. Ask the rest of the class to identify these mistakes and
correct them. Another way is to raise an eyebrow, or say, “Excuse me?” Or the
teacher can ask for repetition without indicating the mistake.
Also
we can employ another approach called, ‘selective correction’. In this case,
the teacher decides to correct only certain errors. These errors can be decided
by the objectives of the lesson, or the exercise that is being done. In other
words, if students are focusing on past simple tense, then only errors related
to this grammatical area need to be corrected. Other mistakes are ignored.
In
conclusion, the teacher can decide which is the most beneficial and effective
approach to error correction based on the situation itself. It will help
students overcome their shyness and play an active role in class discussions
without being afraid of making mistakes. In this case, they would acknowledge
and accept their mistakes as part of the learning process instead of being
offended when they are corrected by their teacher.
The
aim of the research work is to consider what benefits correction of
any kind might have for learners, as well as to present some ideas for
conducting later correction (correction slots).
The
object is theoretical phonetics of the English language.
The
subject of the research work: correcting students’ pronunciation.
The
tasks of research:
1. To analyze theoretical material on the
problem of the research.
2. To reveal peculiarities of English
pronunciation.
3. To investigate new ways and methods of
correcting students’ pronunciation.
Following
methods of the research were used during the writing of the work:
1. study and analyze of methodical
literature;
2. determined observation on usage of
studying materials.
The
source consists of scientific, phonetic materials, teaching aids,
articles on phonetics.
1.
The importance of teaching English pronunciation
Contributing this
particular gift can occasionally be a bit tricky, for several reasons. First,
your students have already studied English for years and their pronunciation
habits are not easy to change. A second problem for those of you who are native
speakers of English is that you produce sounds so naturally that you may not be
aware of how you do it, so even when you know that your students' pronunciation
is wrong, you may not know what the problem is or how to correct it. Finally,
the overwhelming majority of Amity teachers are not native speakers of the
British "RP" accent ("Received Pronunciation", also known
as "BBC English" or "the Queen's English") which is the
accepted English standard in Kazakhstan in most textbooks, including Junior and
Senior English for Kazakh. (Even in the UK, this accent is spoken by only
a fairly small minority.) The upshot of all this is that teaching pronunciation
may a more complicated issue than it seems.
The
good news, however, is that through dint of hard effort it is possible for
students to make some improvement in their pronunciation, particularly when
they are attending to their pronunciation. (In other words, even future
teachers with fairly heavy accents can learn to pronounce words accurately
enough when paying attention that they provide an acceptable model for their
own students.) If you pay attention to your own pronunciation, and spend a
little time browsing through typical Kazakh English textbooks, you
should also be able to learn enough about the mechanics of pronunciation to be
able to help students. Finally, as long as you are aware of the differences
between your own accent and RP, you can provide a useful pronunciation model
for your students.
In
class, speak naturally using your own accent, although if there are marked
regional features to your speech you might lean as far in the direction of a
more broadly accepted standard as is comfortable for you.
Learn
the differences between your accent and RP. If you are not familiar with the
International Phonetic Alphabet and the accepted RP pronunciation of words.
When
teaching pronunciation, in places where your accent differs from RP, don't
insist that students follow you rather than the standard. (Future teachers will
need to teach the standard in textbooks.) Rather, point out the difference
between your accent and the standard so that students are aware of it.
Many
of the pronunciation problems you encounter in students will have less to do
with the fine tuning of a particular English accent than with simply getting
them to pronounce words in a way that is more or less acceptable in any variety
of English, so focus your efforts on the many areas where you can help students
in their pronunciation. [1,52]
1.1
Ancient and Modern Pronunciations
We
cannot be sure exactly how the ancient Romans pronounced their Latin, although
the discipline of Historical Linguistics has given us a reasonably good idea of
their general spoken practice. The early borrowings from Latin into various
languages give some idea of the Roman pronunciation, for example Gothic
"wins" meaning 'wine' was borrowed from Latin "vinum"; this
shows the -w- pronunciation of -v- in Latin clearly, at least at the time that
the borrowing took place.
In
English speaking countries, two problems arise: First, are we to pronounce -v-
as -w- is pronounced in English, or like English -v-? And then are we to say
-ch- for Latin -c-, palatalizing the consonant before the fronted vowels, as in
Italian, or pronounce it like English hard -k-? Teachers trained in the tradition
of the Catholic Church will generally use the fricative -v- and the palatalized
-ch-, others will use the other sounds, which the majority of modern scholars
feels to be more authentic. A great deal of heat, if not light, has been spent
on the problem of the "correct pronunciation of Latin". Probably most
students will go with the method that their teachers use., but whichever way
you follow, remember that this is a matter of scholarship, not of religion or
faith. If there is any overriding parameter of judgment, it should probably be
on the side of convenience, but in the last analysis the student who is really
concerned with the way Latin may have sounded, as a part of his esthetic
appreciation of a poet like Vergil, must try to find out the best way, so far
as he can determine it, and follow it.
One
person finds it ludicrous to read Vergil with an accent which appeared a
thousand years after the poet's death; but another reads Vergil the way Dante
read him, thinking this is good enough for him. Here as elsewhere de gustibus
non disputandum est.
But
if you are going to try to read Latin authentically, be sure you do not
aspirate the stop-consonants, which is one of the oddities of English which
makes the study of English so far for most others. It is virtually necessary to
say "arpor" for 'tree" in order to avoid the Anglicized
"arbhor". We know from grammarians that the Romans said
"urps" for the city of Rome, and this is probably typical of their
general pronunciation of the stop consonants. Furthermore, you should not use
that nondescript English -r-, but roll your -r- broadly, as most of the Romanic
language do. Whether it is a tongue trill, or a throat rumble is not important,
so long as it isn't an English vanishing- consonant with a tongue flap (like
"berry" pronounced 'Betty') or an American hybrid.
More
important is the matter of the pronunciation of verse, for which see Section
14) of this supplement for a full discussion. The substitution of stressed
accent in the place of genuinely LONG vowels is arbitrary and quite against the
nature of both Greek and Latin poetry, which was length-conscious without any
special attention to stress. If this process is justified by saying that it is
a habit, understand that it is a bad habit, and please cut it out. Substituting
STRESS for LENGTH is about as sensible as tapping your foot every time you hear
a Chinese rising tone. [2,56]
Incidentally
much the same misfortune has accrued to the sensitive and lovely Classical
Greek language, where a perfectly attested pitch inflection of a musical fifth
(marked by an acute accent in the Alexandrian period for the benefit of
benighted foreigners like us) is regularly replaced by a heavy stress. This
identical stress is also used for the circumflex, which loses its double-length
and up-and-down musical inflection, so reminiscent of Swedish. And (believe it
or not!) this same stress is used for the grave, which is nothing more than the
replacement of an acute by a low (barytone) at base level, and is so marked in
some extant papyri on every syllable for real dunderheads in the Alexandrian
schools. But for the pig-headed, caution to the winds!
If
you did these thoughtless things to modern Bengali, people would fail to
understand you, or jeer if you persisted. But since the Classical peoples are
not around to defend themselves, it look like a case linguistic open-season on
whatever is around. But the bottom line: You are losing authenticity, and more
important a large measure of esthetic appreciation.
1.2
Listening and pronunciation
Unless
you are fortunate enough to have very small classes, it will be difficult to
give much individual attention to students' pronunciation. Students must
therefore learn to rely on their ears to tell them whether their pronunciation
approximates that of native speaker models. However, many students are not in
the habit of listening carefully before attempting to repeat. In fact, they
have often been trained for years to immediately repeat whatever the teacher
says, no matter how vague their impression is of the jumble of sounds they are
trying to reproduce. Another problem is that while students are listening to
the teacher's spoken model, their attention is often focused more on preparing
to repeat than on listening. The teacher's sentence consequently serves less as
a model for pronunciation than as a starting shot announcing that students
should try to speak.
The
first approach to pronunciation is thus helping students develop the habit of
listening carefully before they speak. To do this, the first time you say a
word or sentence, ask students to listen just listen. They should not murmur
the utterance quietly after you; instead they should concentrate on fixing the
sound in their memories. It is helpful if you repeat the model utterance
several times before asking students to repeat; this not only allows them more
chances to listen but also helps students break the habit of blurting out a
response as soon as you finish.
Exercises
which require listening but no oral response may also help sharpen student
listening skills. Minimal pair drills are particularly good for helping
students learn to hear the difference between similar sounds. Minimal pairs are
words that are pronounced exactly the same with the exception of one sound (Ex:
pin--pen, bid--bit). Sample exercise: To help students learn to hear the
difference between the short "i" and "e" sounds, ask
students to raise their pen when you say the word "pen" and a pin
when you say "pin."
Training
students' ability to hear sound distinctions will not necessarily result in
good pronunciation. However, students who have not clearly heard a sound
obviously have less chance to produce it correctly than those who listen
carefully. [3,47]
1.3
Modelling pronunciation
Most
native speakers of English have not formally studied the mechanics of English
pronunciation, so this is an area in which it would be helpful to do some
homework so that you are prepared to explain how sounds are made if called on
to do so. However, you will almost certainly be expected to serve as a model
for pronunciation, and for this purpose a limited amount of choral drill can be
useful. Steps for such a drill would be as follows:
1)
Choose a text that represents normal spoken English (as opposed to more bookish
language). A dialog from your textbook would be a good choice.
2)
Read sentences aloud, clearly but at a fairly normal speed. Have students
listen to each sentence once or twice before attempting to repeat it. Remind
them that they should be listening to and trying to mimic the rhythm, stress,
and intonation patterns of your speech as well as your pronunciation.
3)
Build up longer sentences from the end, starting with the last few words, and
then adding the previous ones. Ex: "...give you money?"
"...expect me to give you money?" "Do you really expect me to
give you money?" (This approach tends to preserve sentence intonation
better than working from the beginning.)
One
fun way to practice the rhythm of English sentences is by taking a dialog from
a book, preferably one with short sentences, and turning it into a "jazz
chant." In essence, this means finding the natural rhythm of each sentence
and then chanting it with emphasis on the key words, something like a group
cheer at a football game or a chant at a protest rally ("Hell no, we won't
go" and so forth). Clapping or pounding desks adds to the festive nature
of the activity. This exercise is particularly good for driving home the point
that not all words in English sentences get equal stress.
Suggestions:
If
you want students to prepare choral drill of a dialog before class, it is best
if they have a taped model to work with. Without having heard a dialog before
they repeat it, they may wind up polishing an incorrect performance.
Choral
drill is best in small doses. It generally only takes a short period of drill
for students to get the point you wish to make, and drill beyond that point
rapidly turns into mindless parroting. [4,58]
1.4
Performance of a text
Once
students are able to repeat accurately after a spoken model, the next step is
to have them practice speaking from a written text. Keeping pronunciation
accurate while reading a text aloud is more difficult than repeating after a
teacher, but it is still easier for students than maintaining correct
pronunciation in free conversation because they can focus their attention on
pronunciation rather than grammar or word choice.
One
way to do this is to choose a text and copy it for students. If the goal is to
teach daily conversational English, it is best if the text represents normal
spoken English, though an argument can be made for sometimes including texts of
literary and cultural merit (famous orations, poems, etc.) that were also
intended to be read aloud or recited. Having chosen a text, go over it with
students in class and have them take whatever notes they need on pronunciation,
syllable stress, sentence intonation and stressed words. Next have students
practice reading the text aloud (either in class or at home). Students should
become very familiar with the text. Finally, either have students perform the
text in class or -- if the equipment is available -- have them tape a reading
of the text. The advantages of the latter approach are that students don't all
have to listen to each other read the same text, and that you can listen at
your leisure. [5,95]
1.5
Aspects of pronunciation
Many
students tend to think of pronunciation primarily as accurate production of the
sounds of English words, but this is neither the only aspect of the problem nor
the only important one. Consequently, one way in which you can help students
improve is by ensuring that they are aware of all of the important issues. (see Appendix
4)
1)
Accurate pronunciation of sounds: This is really two problems, one of ability
and one of knowledge. Students first need to learn to pronounce as many of the
sounds of English as possible accurately. The particular sounds with which
students will have difficulty depend to a large extent on students' first
language, but there are some sounds in English such as the "th"
sounds in "think" and "this", or the short vowels in
"head," "hit," and "put" which are difficult for
students from many language backgrounds.
The
second problem is making sure that students know what sounds they should
pronounce in a given word. Common pronunciation problems include omitting
sounds, adding extra ones, or simply pronouncing the wrong sound.
2)
Syllable stress: Unlike many other languages, English requires that one
syllable in each word be stressed more than others. The importance of putting
the stress on the right syllable in English cannot be underestimated; putting
the stress on the wrong syllable is more likely to make a word unintelligible
than is mispronouncing one of its sounds. For many students who are especially
hard to understand, misplaced syllable stress is the main problem.
3)
Sentence word stress: In English sentences, not all words are given equal
emphasis. Key words (usually the words that contain new or important
information) are stressed and pronounced more slowly and clearly than other
words. Take, for example, the question "Are you going to go to
Boston?" If the focus of the question is on where the listener will go,
the sentence will sound something like "Ya gonna go ta Boston"; the
word "Boston" would be pronounced clearly and with more emphasis. If,
in contrast, the emphasis is on who is going, the sentence would sound like
"Are you gonna go ta Boston?" While students don't necessarily need
to learn to reduce the unimportant words in sentence, they should learn to
stress key ones. (Students should also be made aware of English word reductions
for listening comprehension.)
4)
Sentence intonation: Intonation patterns in English sentences primarily
indicate the degree of certainty of an utterance, i.e. whether it is a
statement, question, or suggestion. Statements rise to a plateau, and then end
with falling intonation. Most questions end in rising intonation; however, Wh-
questions (who, what, where, when, why and how) end with falling intonation. It
is important for students to learn these patterns not only in order to
communicate meaning, but also in order to avoid unwittingly sounding rude or
indecisive.
5)
Enunciation: A final important aspect of pronunciation is clear enunciation.
Some students lack confidence in speaking or are unsure of their pronunciation,
and therefore speak either very quietly or unclearly. Obviously this makes them
more difficult to understand, and students should therefore be reminded that
speaking audibly and clearly is an important aspect of pronunciation.
The
ideal approach to student pronunciation problems is for you to work
individually with each student, listening for problems, explaining the proper
pronunciation (intonation, etc.), modelling correct pronunciation, and
listening to the student practice. However, this is usually not possible
because of time limitations and class size, so the discussion below will focus
on approaches which can be used with a class. [6,52]
1.6
The role of teaching Pronunciation in FLT
Teaching
English pronunciation is an area of language teaching that many English
teachers avoid. While there are many textbooks and instruction manuals
available, as well as books on the theories and methodologies of language
teaching there is comparatively little on learning pronunciation.
Why?
Is it because we don't need to teach pronunciation or because it cannot be
taught?
Certainly,
we need to teach pronunciation. There is a big difference between a ship and a
sheep and a pear and a bear! When teaching any language as a foreign or second
language, our first goal for our students is basic communication, and that
can't happen if no one can understand what they are saying.
How
NOT to Teach Pronunciation
When
teachers decide to focus on pronunciation practise many of them make the
mistake of trying to teach pronunciation along with introducing vocabulary.
This can work with students who have a "good ear," or who perhaps
speak a related language. However it can be hit and miss with students whose
mother tongue has no relation to the target language.
This
brings us back to the question of whether pronunciation can be effectively
taught at all? The answer is yes, of course it can be taught, it's just that
the way many textbooks tell us to teach it is actually one of the least
effective.
Most
textbooks will have you drill pronunciation with repetition of the vocabulary.
Some of the better ones will have you work on it with spelling, which is an
important skill, especially in English with its many irregularities and
exceptions. Very few will start you and your students where you need to start,
however, and that is at the level of the phoneme.
Start
with Phonemes (but not necessarily phonetic script)
The
dictionary defines "phoneme" as "any of the perceptually distinct
units of sound in a specified language that distinguish one word from another,
for example p, b, d, and t in the English words pad, pat, bad, and bat."
This definition highlights one of the key reasons that we must, as language
teachers, start our pronunciation instruction at the level of the phoneme. If a
phoneme is a "perceptually distinct unit of sound" then we have to
realize that before students can consistently produce a given phoneme, they
must be able to hear it. Thus the first lessons in pronunciation should involve
your students listening and identifying, rather than speaking. [7,85]
Introduce
your phonemes in contrasting pairs like /t/ and /d/. Repeat the phonemes in
words as well as in isolation and ask the students to identify them. In order
to visually represent the differences they are listening for, you may want to
draw pronunciation diagrams for each sound showing the placement of the tongue
and lips.
You
might also consider teaching your students the necessary symbols from the
phonetic alphabet, because although T and D are written differently in English,
the TH in "there" and the TH in "thanks" are written
exactly the same, despite the difference in pronunciation. This isn't
essential, and really works best with adults rather than children, but it is
worth it for any students who are highly visual or analytical learners.
You
can play all sorts of matching games with this material to make the drills more
fun and less stressful. You can have students play with nonsense sounds and
focus on the tiny differences between contrasted phonemic pairs, the key being
to get them to hear the phoneme.
All
these games are included in the English Language Games Digital Book for adults
with 163 games and activities!
From
Recognition of Phonemes to Practise
Once
they can hear and identify a phoneme, it's time to practice accurate production
of the sound. For this, pronunciation diagrams are useful. Your students need to
be able to see where to put their lips and tongues in relation to their teeth.
Most sounds are articulated inside your mouth and students have no idea what
you are doing in order to produce that particular noise. If you have ever tried
to teach a Japanese student how to say an American /r/, then you have
experienced the frustration of trying to get a student to produce tongue
movements they can't see. There are books out there with diagrams, and with a
little practice you can probably produce sketches of them yourself. If you
can't, get hold of a good reference book so that you can flip to the relevant
pages. Your students will thank you for this insight into the mouth, especially
since there is no danger of the embarrassment of bad breath with a drawing. [8, 26]
While
this may sound time consuming and unnat