Difficulties in Translation of Publicistic Headlines and their Pragmatic Aspect
Difficulties in Translation of Publicistic Headlines and their Pragmatic Aspect
MINISTRY
OF EDUCATION, YOUTH AND SPORTS
CAHUL
STATE UNIVERSITY “B. P. HASDEU”
PHILOLOGI
DEPARTMENT
ENGLISH
AND FRENCH LANGUAGE AND LITERATURE
THEME
Difficulties in Translation of Publicistic Headlines
and
their Pragmatic Aspect
CAHUL
2010
Introduction
Publicistic
Headline is known as the name of literature, scientific or musical produce. Our
research on publicistic headline will study a lot of its definition. We shall
notice similarity between them as well. According to Kukharenco V.A., headline
is a text at the top of a newspaper article, indicating the nature of the
article below it.
Galperin finds
the headline a dependent from of newspaper writing. Its main function is to
inform the reader briefly about the text which follows it.
The main goal
of this research paper is to analyze publicistic headline from difficulties in
translation of publicistic headlines and their pragmatic aspect.
The
objectives of the given work are:
- To define
publicistic Headline.
- to present
classification and structure of the publicistic headlines.
- to reveal
linguistic peculiarities of publicistic headlines.
- to explain
ways of translation the publicistic headlines and difficulties in translation
the publicistic headlines.
- to analyze
the pragmatic functions and difficulties in translation of publicistic
headlines.
We have worked
much to complete our goal. The critical analysis of the scientific literature
has been fulfilled by us.
While writing
this paper we have addressed to such sources as manuals, monographs,
dictionaries and, of course publicistic works. In our research we have used
explanation and analysis as scientific theoretical methods. As for the
structure of the work, it falls into three chapters.
The first chapter
deals with the theory concerning publicistic style. It is divided into four
parts: 1) defining the Publicistic Headline; 2) classification and structure of
the publicistic headlines; 3) linguistic peculiarities of publicistic headlines;
4) on the applicability of publicistic headlines; 5) publicistic headlines
under pragmatic aspect.
In this
chapter we defined the Publicistic Headline and their classification and
structure. Also we showed the publicistic headlines under pragmatic aspect. We
wrote about linguistic peculiarities and their applicability of publicistic
headlines.
The second
chapter is devoted to the
translability of publicistic headlines. It is also falls into
three parts: 1) on the approaches of translation used in Newspaper Style; 2) on
the ways of translation the publicistic headlines; 3) on the difficulties in
translation the publicistic headlines.
We defined
approaches of translation the Publicistic Headline in Newspaper Style and wrote
about different ways of translation. Also in this chapter we wrote difficulties
in translation the publicistic headlines.
The third
chapter: establishing pragmatic value
of publicistic headlines and difficulties of their translation from English
into Russian. It is falls into two parts:
In the first we analyze publicistic headlines and their Pragmatic
functions. And the second in difficulties in translation of publicistic
headlines.
It is all
theoretical and practical parts of our research paper about what we will write.
1.1 Defining the Publicistic Headline
The general
definition of Headline is the name of literature, scientific or musical
produce. Many dictionaries define Headline as a short summary of the most
important items of news read at the beginning of a news programme on the radio
or television. Headline is one of the basic newspaper features. The headline is
the title given to a news item or newspaper article.
To make
headlines (grab; hit) means to be an important item of news in newspapers or on
radio or television. To headline (usually passive) means to give a story or
article a particular headline:
War breaks out
in Europe
Atomic bomb
dropped on Hiroshima
Man walks on
Moon
Headlines very
often contain emotionally colored words and phrases. To produce a strong
emotional effect, broken-up set expressions and deformed special terms are
commonly used. The Headline of news items apart from giving information about the
subject-matter, also carry a considerable amount of appraisal. Headlines are
usually written in bold and in a much larger size than the article text. Front
page headlines are often in upper case so that they can be easy read by the
potential customer. Headlines in other parts of the paper are more commonly in
sentence case though title case is often used in the USE.
The
characteristics features of Headlines are the most condensed piece of
information on minimum of space. Galperin mentions typical stylistic patterns
of Headlines.
a. Full
declarative sentences.
e.g. ’China
lifts price of domestic oil products’. (Financial Times).
b.
Interrogative sentences.
e. g. ‘It the
kitchen finished? (The Sun).
c. Nominative
sentences.
e.g. ‘Cautious
start for bourses’ (Financial Times).
d. Elliptical
sentences.
e.g. Child
drunk griever banned’ (The Sun).
e. Sentences
with articles omitted.
e. g. ‘PM
warns against hostility to US’. (Daily Express).
f. Phrases
with verbal- infinitive and gerundial.
e.g. ‘Keeping
it in the family pays off for baker’. (The Times).
g. Questions
in the form of statements.
e.g. ‘Health
food?’ (The Times).
h. Headlines
including direct speech.
e. g. ‘Blair:
I should never have revealed I was quitting’. (Mirror).
Headline
conventions include normally using present tense and omitting ‘a’ and ‘the’ as
well as forms of the verb ‘to be’ in certain context. [2, p.75]
- The Present
Simple is also used to describe actions as instant, happening in a moment. For
actions over a period, we use the continuous.
e.g. United
are playing really well now.
The crowd is
cheering them on.
Most newspaper
features a very large Headline on their front page, dramatically describing the
biggest news of the day. Headline is the most basic text organizing tool used
to invite the reader to become involved with the publication. Limit headlines
to no more than three lines. A headline is text at the top of a newspaper
article, indicating the nature of the article below it. A headline which is
called – banner headline. The Headline (the title given to a news item or an
article) is a dependent form of newspaper writing. It is in part of a large
whole. The specific functional and linguistic features of the headline provide
sufficient ground for isolating and analyzing it as a specific ‘genre’ of
journalism.
1.2
Classification and structure of the publicistic headlines
The main
function of the headline is to inform the reader briefly of what the news that
follows is about. Sometimes headlines show the reporter’s or paper’s attitude
of the fact reported. In most of the English and American newspapers
sensational headlines are quite common. The function and the peculiar nature of
English headlines determine the choice of language means used. [4, p.35]
Headlines also contain emotionally colored words and phrases as the italicized
words: ’Crazy waste of you? Syntactically headlines are very short sentences or
phrases and have a variety of pattern.
A.
Full
declarative sentences.
B.
Interrogative
sentences.
C.
Nominative
sentences ‘Atlantic sea Traffic’.
D.
Elliptical
sentences ‘Off to the Sun ‘.
E.
Sentences
with articles omitted. (Articles are frequently omitted in all types of
headline). ‘Frock man find gold in river ‘.
F.
Complex
sentences.
G.
Headlines
including direct speech.
The Headlines
in English language newspapers can be very difficult to understand. One reason
for this is that newspaper headlines are often written in a special style,
which is very difficult from ordinary English. In this style there are special
rules of grammar and words are often used in unusual ways.
a.
Headlines
are not always complete sentences. Many headlines consist of noun phrases with
no verb.
-
More wage cuts.
-
Holiday Hotel Death.
b.
Headlines
often contain string of three, four or more nouns; nouns earlier in the string
modify those that follow.
-
Furniture factory pay cut row.
Headlines like
these can be difficult to understand. It sometimes helps to read them
backwards. Furniture Factory Pay Cut Row (disagreement) about a Cut (reduction)
in Pay at a Factory that makes Furniture.
c.
Headlines
often leave out articles and the verb ‘be’.
- A
woman walks on moon.
d. In
headlines, simple tenses are often used instead of progressive or perfect
forms. The simple present is used for both present and past events.
-
Blind girl climbs Everest (=…has climbed…).
-
Student fight for course changes (=…has fighting …).
The present
progressive can be used, especially to talk about changes. Be is usually
dropped.
-
Britain getting warmer, say scientist.
-
Trade figures improving.
e. Many
headlines words are used as both nouns and verbs, and nouns are often used to
modify other nouns. So it is not always easy to work out the structure of a
sentence. Compare:
- We
cuts aid to third world (= The Us reduced its help…cuts is a verb, aid is a
noun).
- Aid
Cuts Row (= There has been a disagreement about the reduction in aid. Aid and
Cuts is both noun).
-
Cuts Aid Rebels (= the reduction in aid is helping the revolutionaries. Cuts is
a noun, Aid is a verb).
f. Headlines
often use infinitives to refer to the future.
- PM
to visit Australia.
-
Hospitals to take fewer patients.
For is also
used to refer to future movements or plants.
-
TROOPS FOR GLASGOW? (= Are soldiers going to be sent to Glasgow?).
g. Auxiliary
verbs are usually dropped from passive structures, leaving past participles.
-
Murder Hunt: Man Held (=…a man is being held by police.)
- Six
killed In Explosion (=Six people have been killed…).
Note that
forms like held, attacked are usually part participles with passive meanings,
not past tenses (which are rare are newspaper headlines). Compare:
- AID
ROW: PRESTDENT ATTACTED (=…The President has attacked.)
- AID
ROW: PRESTDENT ATTACTED CRITICS (=…The President has attacked her critics.)
- Boy
Found Safe (= The missing boy had been found safe.)
- Boy
Find Safe (= A boy has found a safe.)
h. A color is
often used to separate the subject of a headline from what is said about it.
Strikes: PM to
ACT.
Motorway
crash: Death toll rises. Quotation marks (‘…’) are used to show that words were
said by some else, and that the newspaper does not necessarily claim that they
are time.
- Crash
Driver ‘Had been drinking’
A question
mark (?) is often used when something is not certain.
-
Crisis over by September?
Short words
save space, and so they are very common in newspaper headlines. Some of the
short words in headlines are unusual in ordinary language (e.g. curb, meaning
’restrict’ or ‘restriction’), and some are used in special senses which they do
not often have in ordinary language (e.g. big, meaning ‘attempt’). Other words
are chosen not because they are short, but because they sound dramatic (e.g.
blare, which means ‘big fire’, and is used in headlines to refer to any fire). The
following is a list of common headline vocabulary.
Act - take
action: do something.
-Foot Crisis:
Government to act.
Aid – military
or financial help: to help
-More aid for
poor countries.
-Unions aid
hospital strikers.
Alert – alarm,
warning.
-Flood alert
on east coast.
Allege – make
on accusation.
- Woman
alleges unfair treatment.
Appears –
appear in court accused of a crime.
- MP to appear
on drugs charges.
Axe – abolish,
close down: abolition, closure.
- Country bus
services axed.
- Small
schools face axe.
Knowledge as
to the usage of the pun’s mechanisms in publicity lead to better understanding
of the specificity of English press and may be used in the theory of
translation or during the creation of newspaper or advertisement headline with
the help of a pun.
The headline
(the title given to a news item or article) is a dependent form of newspaper
writing. It is in fact a part of a larger whole. The specific functional and
linguistic features of the headline provide sufficient ground for isolating and
analyzing it as a specific “genre” of journalism. The main function of the headline
is to inform the reader briefly what the text that follows is about. But apart
from its, headlines often contain elements of appraisal i.e. they show the
reporter’s or the paper’s attitude to the facts reported or commented on, thus
also performing the function of instructing the reader.
English
headlines are short and catching; they “compact the gist of news stories into a
few eye-snaring words. A skillfully turned out headlines tells a story, or
enough of it, to arouse or satisfy the reader’s curiosity.”
Such group
headlines are almost a summary of the information contained in the news item or
article.
The functions
and the peculiar nature of English headlines predetermine the choice of the
language means used. The vocabulary groups considered in the analysis of brief
news items are commonly found in headlines.
An excellent
way for a more advanced learner to increase their English proficiency is to
read an English-language newspaper on a regular basis. Most people who read a
newspaper do so selectively and skim though the pages looking for the most
interesting-looking articles to read first. They usually make their choice on
the basis of the headlines of the articles. And this is where the difficulty
for the non-native speaker of English arises, since newspaper headlines are
often extremely difficult to understand. There are two main reasons for this.
The first reason is that newspaper headlines have to be brief and consequently
use words that are rarely used in everyday speech or indeed in the rest of the
article itself. (Probe for investigation, blast for explosion etc.) And the
second reason is that headline writers, at least in British newspapers, look
for every opportunity to include a pun in their headlines. It is the main
aspect of newspaper headlines that we want to concentrate on in this work.
All the
headlines of all types (primary or page headlines, secondary or paper
headlines, paper subsection headlines, leads and captions) of the local daily
called Kauno diena) is emotionally destructive and people should be aware of
this in order to diminish its emotional impact.
By the basic
functions of newspaper titles nominativna, informing, communicative, and also
pragmatic or attraktivna, that will realize the action of text, his having a
special purpose orientation. Exactly some researchers consider this function
basic, as setting of title consists above all things in bringing in of
attention to the article, in creation of stimulus for its reading, which is
often achieved by the use of the system of expressive means of languages, among
which an important place is taken a play on words.
1.3 Linguistic peculiarities of publicistic headlines
The role of
newspaper in the nowadays life and its influence on the modern society is generally
recognized. The printed media remains one of the oldest a most effective way to
communicate the freshness news. Newspaper has the following basic features:
brief news items, advertisements and announcements, the editorial and the
headline. This paper investigates only one element of the newspaper- the
headline.
By the
pragmatic effect of application of play on words in this title arising up as a
result of combination of frock’n’roll, that is paradoxical on character and
owns a fully certain estimating plan is something amusing and unusual.
Appropriately to assume that speech in the article will go about the place of
woman in modern music. A question is this serious, however estimating a plan,
formed the element of frock that is brought in a title complex bring in the
tint of sarcasm in the supposed interpretation of problem the author of the
article.
The following
title gives the very dim picture of Te, what theme of the article:
Ugly noises
from Los Angeles mayor’s nest
An author
orients a reader in the value of attitude toward the described facts, them
marks and uses a play on words: mayor’s nest omonimichno mare’s nest – to
expression, that a “senseless device” means, and the question is about
machinations on selections, thus one of candidates – mer city Los-Angeles. A
pun in dannomu case carries expressively stylistic information which represents
author emotionally evaluation attitude toward an object, or expressively
cognitive setting of this linguistic registration of idea. Negative attitude of
author is here traced toward a situation which was folded on elections, and a
pun specifies on personality which to a certain extent is herein guilty, and
characterizes her. Except for it, a pun is directed on Te, to come into notice
of reader to the described events and compel him not only to laugh above them
but change their motion. [11, p.52]
The short and
capacious form of this pun is based on the vivid use of languages. Exactly an
associative vivid component adds maintenance a reception convincing and bright
character which predetermines him attractive function. In spite of trouble of
information which is stopped up in a title, a reader gets certain aesthetically
beautiful pleasure at his reading.
Attention is
attracted the satiric orientation of title, reader will want to read a note.
The example of pun, beaten element based on etymologyzation is the English
title:
Sweetest
Tattoo
The article is
about creation of artist I. Isupova, which attained extraordinary trade in art
of tattoo.
In a stylistic
relation this case is imposition: simultaneous actualization and beating of
auditive and etymologic values of word “tattoo” takes place- 1) tattoo; 2) prohibition
[11, p.772]. Connection of metaphoric-metonymy appears between LSV: overt associations
(tattoo –that it is forbidden) and transferences for contiguity (prohibition as
subject action and tattoo is as a result of this prohibition), and epithet of
“sweetest” – the “sweet” contains illusion on biblical really a fruit is forbidden.
Tempting and beauty of tattoo is in a great deal conditioned exactly the
prohibition imposed on her. The use in the title of English dissemination has,
cleanly linguistic base: the semantic structure of the English noun of “tattoo”,
unlike proper him loan-word in Russian (what has one only, visual value),
enables to express in one entrance both LSV of this unit. In the considered
example is very brightly expressed marked researchers pragmatic a meaningful
feature of pun is aspiring to most semantic capacity at the use of the least of
means of languages.
The article
about plagiarism of sings of commodities is published under a title: Sony
against Soni. The article of beating and mean of creation of visual effect is
exactly different graphic design components of pun at community of their
sounding.
1.4 On the
applicability of publicistic headlines
The
publicistic style has its spoken variety – the radio and TV
Commentaries
and the oratorical sub – style. The written sub – styles are the essay and
journalistic articles in newspapers, magazines and journals. The basic aim of
the publicistic style is to exert an influence on public opinion, to convince
the reader or the listener that the interpretation given by the writer or the speaker
is correct and to make them accept his or her views though logical
argumentation and emotional appeal. [13.p.159] The development of the radio and
television has brought into a new spoken variety namely the radio commentary.
The other two are the essay (moral, social, economic) in newspapers and
magazines. The general aim as we have said is to exert a constant and deep
influence on public opinion. Publicistic style is also characterized by brevity
of expression. In some varieties of this style it becomes a leading feature and
important linguistic means. In essays brevity sometimes becomes epigrammatic. [14.p.824]
The most characteristic language features of the essay remain:
- Brevity of
expression
- The use of
the first person singular which justified a personal approach treated.
- The use of
emotive words.
- The use of
similes and metaphors.
Some essay
depending on the writer’s individuality is written in a highly emotional manner
resembling the style of emotive prose. Others resemble scientific prose. The
essay in our days is often biographical: persons; facts and events are taken
from life. These essays differ from those of previous centuries, their
vocabulary is simpler.
1.5
Publicistic headlines under pragmatic aspect
Pragmatics studies the factors that govern our choice of
language in social interaction and the effects of our choice on others.
Pragmatics is concerned with the study of meaning as
communicated by a speaker (or writer) and interpreted by a listener (or
reader). It has, consequently, more to do with the analysis of what people mean
by their utterances than what the words or phrases in those utterances might
mean by themselves. Pragmatics is the study of speaker meaning. This type of
study necessary involves the interpretation of what people mean in a particular
context and how the context influences what is said. It requires a consideration
of how speakers organize what to say in accordance with who they’re talking to,
where, when, and under what circumstances. Pragmatics is the study of
contextual meaning. This approach also necessary explores how listeners can
make inferences about what is said in order to arrive at an interpretation of
the speaker’s intended meaning. This type of study explores how a great deal of
what is unsaid is recognized as part of what is communicated. We might say that
it is the investigation of invisible meaning. Pragmatics is the study of how
more gets communicated than is said. This perspective then raises the question
of what determines the choice between the said and the unsaid. The basic answer
is tied to the notion of distance. Closeness, whether it is physical, social,
or conceptual, implies shared experience. On the assumption of how close or
distant the listener is speakers determine how much needs to be said.
Pragmatics is the study of the expression of relative distance. These are the
four areas that pragmatics is concerned with. To understand how it got to be
that way, we have to briefly review its relationship with other areas of
linguistic analysis. [17, p.3] “Pragmatics is all about the meanings between
the lexis and the grammar and the phonology...Meanings are implied and the
rules being followed are unspoken, unwritten ones.”[16, George Keith]
“Pragmatics is a way of investigating how sense can be made
of certain texts even when, from a semantic viewpoint, the text seems to be
either incomplete or to have a different meaning to what is really intended.
Consider a sign seen in a children's wear shop window: “Baby Sale - lots of
bargains”. We know without asking that there are no babies are for sale - that
what is for sale are items used for babies. Pragmatics allows us to investigate
how this “meaning beyond the words” can be understood without ambiguity. The
extra meaning is there, not because of the semantic aspects of the words
themselves, but because we share certain contextual knowledge with the writer
or speaker of the text.
Pragmatics is an important area of study for your course. A
simplified way of thinking about pragmatics is to recognize, for example, that
language needs to be kept interesting - a speaker or writer does not want to
bore a listener or reader, for example, by being over-long or tedious. So,
humans strive to find linguistic means to make a text, perhaps, shorter, more
interesting, more relevant, more purposeful or more personal. Pragmatics allows
this.
George
Keith notes that: “The vast majority of pragmatics studies have been devoted to
conversation, where the silent influence of context and the undercurrents are
most fascinating.
But
he goes on to show how written texts of various kinds can be illuminated by
pragmatics, and he cites particular examples from literature. Pragmatics gives
us ways into any written text. Take the following example, which is a headline
from the Guardian newspaper of May 10, 2002. This read: “Health crisis looms as
life expectancy soars.”
If
we study the semantics of the headline, we may be puzzled. The metaphor (“soars”)
indicates an increase in the average life-expectancy of the UK population. Most
of us are living longer. So why is this crisis for health? Pragmatics supplies
the answer. The headline writer assumes that we share his or her understanding
that the crisis is not in the health or longevity of the nation, but in the
financial cost to our society of providing health care for these long-living
people. The UK needs to pay more and employ more people to provide this care.
Reading the article will show this. Or take any item of unsolicited mail more
or less at random - such as a letter sent to me by Mr. David Moyes, the manager
of Everton Football Club. Mr. Moyes opens with an invitation: “SUPPORT YOUR
TEAM”, followed by the question:
“How would you
like to support Everton and receive some excellent benefits at the same time?”
After
this come details of a Platinum Plus credit card and some associated offers of
free gifts. The letter closes with a copy of Mr. Moyes' signature, with his
name and position (“Team Manager”) in print below. We can conjecture that the
immediate writer of this letter is not Mr. Moyes, but someone with knowledge of
financial products, employed by the club to help raise money from fans. I can
be more confident that this is so, since it is only a few months since I
received a near-identical letter, bearing the signature of the previous
manager, Mr. Walter Smith. The writer assumes that he or she is addressing people
who have at some point described themselves as supporters of Everton FC - the
mail shot will have gone only to names on a database of such potential
cardholders. Closer inspection suggests that the letter does not necessarily
come from the club, as “Everton” appears in a typeface different from the
surrounding text - prompting the thought that the card issuer (MBNA Europe bank
Limited) is the real source of the letter, and has signed up various sporting
clubs to endorse its product. The card issuer understands that recipients of
such offers will rarely wish to apply for a new credit card, and therefore
attempts to exploit my affection for Everton FC as a novel or sentimental
reason to do so. The second half of the opening sentence may reflect a sense that
most supporters do not receive “excellent benefits at the same time” - though
perhaps the humour here is unintended. This kind of practical analysis is a
good exercise. Sometimes a teacher will need to ask stud